Blue Smoke's (NYC) burger, time and time again, gets dissed in various burger "round-ups" (not on that one) and on blogs (here, though) and just about anywhere that people discuss burgers. So much so that each time I read about someone's thoughts on what is one of my favorite burgers I think "surely this person is going to love it. surely." And I'm pretty much always wrong.
My question is: are these people high? Blue Smoke's burger is certainly one of the best restaurant burgers in NYC. I'm sticking to that opinion regardless of what the rest of the world says.